By Michelle Lynn Tackett
Jordan Peele is the toast of Hollywood right now. I have mixed feelings about this. I am glad he is doing well but is he a good writer? He won the Oscar for best original screenplay for Get Out. Here are the reasons I don’t think Get Out deserved the best screenplay.
Spoilers ahead, if you don’t want to know any spoilers, leave now.
Some things don’t make sense in the screenplay. How does Chris get the cotton in his ears with his hands strapped down? How did Chris’s friend find him? Chris suspected the family of being racist, but not his girlfriend (the families’ daughter) wasn’t? There are so many plot holes in the script I could drive a semi-truck through them.
The Characters Are Dumb
More Spoilers ahead. Don’t blame me if the movie is ruined for you.
Gee, I am a young man of color. I go to my girlfriend’s house to meet my future in-laws, some black servants are working there. The light bulb should’ve gone off in his head. He didn’t think Rose didn’t know about it? When he saw the pictures of her with all of the others, why didn’t he go for help? Some of the decisions the characters made in this movie made the teenagers in Friday the 13th movies look smart.
It Doesn’t Add Up
This wealthy family held all these POC against their will, but Chris and Rocky were able to outsmart them and the police? Why didn’t the police come and arrest Chris? How was Chris going to explain this? If this family had so much power? Why didn’t they call for help when Chris started to get the upper-hand? Hollywood Elsewhere did a brilliant critique of the screenplay to Get Out, so some of this is from his article.
The only reason Jodan Peele won the best screenplay is Hollywood doesn’t want people to think they’re racist. A lot of POC directors and writers ignored over the years. One award doesn’t make you pro POC Hollywood. Giving a mediocre screenplay best screenplay doesn’t make you woke. It makes your racism more obvious.